Spinoza and politics radical thinkers balibar, etienne on. His third, less ambitious yet piercingly insightful work on spinoza, spinoza for our time. Etienne balibars lecture spinozas three gods and the modes of communication at the conference of the birkbeck institute for the humanities thinking with spinoza. Spinozas political philosophy stanford encyclopedia of. Spinoza and politics by etienne balibar, warren montag. Spinozas theory of political crisis mcmaster university. But often they are in such a jam that they cant put any plan into operation, and can only trust to luck. Jan 17, 2008 tienne balibar is a french marxist philosopher and the most celebrated student of louis althusser. Balibar sets himself the task of elucidating the intersection, or unity, between spinozas metaphysics and his political works. Reason, religion and politics the relation between the ethics and the theologicalpolitical treatise.
With the work of althusser and balibar, it inaugurated a tradition of post1968 marxist spinozism that continues to influence and appeal. On the limits of political anthropology t his essay extends the arguments of some of the work that i have already devoted to the theme of the relationships between violence and politics, understood as civility. The new spinoza articulates that presence, making the influence and significance of spinoza perfectly clear for a new generation of philosophy. Balibar believes that spinozas political works are already a metaphysics an ontology of powers and their relations and his metaphysics are already a politics again. Desiring to remove religion as a disturbing factor in politics, spinoza advocated the subordination of religion to politics. While in prison, under the dubious accusation of being involved in terrorist activities, negri did not waste his time or wallow in selfpity. In this book the author deepens and extends the work he first developed with immanuel wallerstein in race, nation, class. A rich analysis of spinozas key works within the context of his political, religious and ideological life. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page information wikidata item. Gilles deleuze, etienne balibar, and our guest in this colloquium, antonio negri. With hobbes and locke, spinoza is arguably one of the most important political philosophers of the modern era. Etienne balibar is probably best known for his coauthorship with althusser of the influential book, reading capital in the late 1960s. Exploring the theme of universalism and difference, he addresses such topical questions as european racism, the notion of the border, whether a european citizenship is possible or desirable, violence and politics, and identity and emancipation.
Spinoza and politics etienne balibar, warren montag. The most recent influx of migrants from north african countries to europe resuscitated the european union debate on immigration policy. Moreover, in spinoza s philosophy occurs the most strictly identification between cause. In that work he argues for the view that we should interpret scripture solely on its own terms by carefully studying it, not with any concepts or doctrines that cannot themselves be derived from the text. Treatise on theology and politics early modern texts. Spinozastheory of political crisis by jeremy p livingston, ra.
At a debate in southern california in 2007, the french philosopher alain badiou informed the french philosopher etienne balibar that he, balibar, was a reformist. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Etienne balibar, being a prolific marxist philosopher, seems very much in his element in spinozas system. Etienne balibar succinct and informative fredric jameson a trenchant and exciting analysis of the philosophy of marx immanuel wallerstein. Over 10 million scientific documents at your fingertips. As etienne balibar puts it, the individuals right includes all. Man by nature is a speaking animal and a political animal. Spinozas philosophy of religion is largely contained in the theologicopolitical treatise. More specifically, i will be concerned with how spinoza has. In order to situate spinozas political writings, i will provide a brief overview of the theologicopolitical context of the united provinces, followed by a sketch of intellectual background to these works.
Balibar carefully situates spinoza s major treatises in the period in which they were written. Etienne balibar s spinoza and politics and alexandre matheronsindividu et communaute chez spinoza have beenthe most influential books ofthistrend. Theology and politics benedict or baruch spinoza preface. From individuality to transindividuality a lecture delivered in rijnsburg on may 15, 19931 before justifying the title of this lecture and indicating the source of the terminology i have used, please allow me some preliminary considerations which will serve to explain what i feel to be the issue at stake.
And you, monsieur, balibar replied, are a theologian. Statelessness in the european union is a welcome and timely. One example is the famous formula from the eighteenth brumaire of i. Add one setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your universitys proxy server configure custom proxy use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy. Extreme violence and the problem of civility, politics as war and war as politics, individuality and transindividuality, borders and the representation of the stranger, universalism and cosmopolitics, etc. Balibar sets himself the task of elucidating the intersection, or unity, between spinoza s metaphysics and his political works.
The political thought of etienne balibar is framed between transindividuality and equaliberty. In spinoza and politics, balibar explores the thought of spinoza with a zeal and alacrity that brings home many of spinozas timeless ideas in political philosophy, even for those who have never read spinoza himself. If he acts for any of these reasons, he is still acting in accordance with the command of the supreme power, and his doing so falls under the general heading of things that the subject does in accordance with the governments commands. I shall call the first concept the autonomy of politics, and i shall link this with the ethical figure of emancipation. With the work of althusser and balibar, it inaugurated a. Politics and the other scene etienne balibar, professor. Spinoza wanted that state to have sufficient power to effectively battle the clergy and their various brands of intolerance. Spinoza s philosophy of religion is largely contained in the theologicopolitical treatise. Etienne balibar three concepts of politics konspektid.
Etienne balibar and sandro mezzadra in conversation audioenglish. Both of these epithets say something, alas, about why badiou, sells better in america than balibar. Written by the dutch philosopher baruch spinoza, the tractatus theologicopoliticus ttp or theologicopolitical treatise was one of the most controversial texts of the early modern period. This paper aims at examining the relation of althusser to communism, its levels and instances, as well as the transformations. Balibar believes that spinoza s political works are already a metaphysics an ontology of powers and their relations and his metaphysics are already a politics again. Politics and postmodernity, further nuances these previous readings. Whereas studies of spinoza in english have emphasized the logic of the ethics, these essays instead focus on the marginal and developmental moments that have had such a profound effect on french thought. This paper has the subtitle, in quo demonstratur, quomodo societas, ubi imperium monarchicum locum habet, sicut et ea, ubi optimi imperant, debet institui, ne in tyrannidem labatur, et ut pax, libertasque civium inviolata maneat. Tractatus politicus tp or political treatise is a political paper by baruch spinoza written in 167576 and published posthumously in 1677. In spinoza s ethics, freedom seems to have no place in an absolute and necessary order of causality.
A dialogue between alain badiou and etienne balibar on universalism, university of california irvine, february 2, 2007. It was a preemptive defense clarification needed of spinoza s later work, ethics, published posthumously in 1677, for which he anticipated harsh criticism. Spinoza and the politics of the future 65 interpretation, advanced by jonathan israel among others, spinoza is the precursor of the radical wing of enlightenment, the theorist of a fullyfledged individualism who breaks with the old regime of absolutism with the embrace of the modern ideas of democracy, equality and free expression of thought. It was written between 1661 and 1675 and was first published posthumously in 1677 the book is perhaps the most ambitious attempt to apply the method of euclid in philosophy. With hobbes and locke, spinoza is arguably one of the most important political philosophers of the modern era, a premier theoretician of democracy and mass politics. It was a preemptive defense clarification needed of spinozas later work, ethics, published posthumously in 1677, for which he anticipated harsh criticism. Treatise on theology and politics showing that piety and civil peace are not harmed by allowing freedom of thought, but are destroyed by the abolition of freedom of thought. Balibar e 2002 ambiguous universality, reprinted as chapter 8 in politics. Etienne balibar spinoza and politics pdf on ideology. In spinoza and politics, balibar explores the thought of spinoza with a zeal and alacrity that brings home many of spinozas timeless ideas in political philosophy. Truth strategy for secular tolerance, illustrated by spinoza and wittgenstein.
From individuality to transindividuality a lecture delivered in rijnsburg on may 15, 19931 before justifying the title of this lecture and indicating the source of the terminology i have used, please allow me some preliminary considerations which will serve to explain what i. He is also one of the leading exponents of french marxist philosophy and the author of spinoza and politics, the philosophy of marx and coauthor of race, nation and class and reading capital. It was written between 1661 and 1675 and was first published posthumously in 1677. The tension in negris dual assertion of spinozas constructive theory of natural right on one hand and his unequal individuals from the viewpoint of power on the other speaks, in fact, to the profound ambiguity in spinoza about the politics of liberation and what we might today imagine as a politics free from capital namely. Pdf equaliberty notes on the thought of etienne balibar. Power, politics, and religion in spinozas political thought 79 the nature of spinozas political theory spinozas political philosophy is unique because it is the only powerbased, as opposed to rightsbased, form of liberalism. Spinoza and politics radical thinkers etienne balibar on. This book, even though it was from italy, could be said to be part of a veritable renaissance in spinoza studies in france in the 1960s, as usefully explained in the. I had only read bits of spinoza s ethics when i read this book, and the bits i had read. Etienne balibars spinoza and politics and alexandre matheronsindividu et communaute chez. The politics of spinozism composition and communication alberto toscano. Theology and politics benedict or baruch spinoza 17. Sep 08, 2014 a read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. He has taught at the university of paris xnanterre.
Spinoza and politics books pics download new books and. By contrast, i shall call the second concept the heteronomy of politics, or politics. In 2004, negri wrote subversive spinoza, extending his work in savage anomaly and continuing his radical renewal of marxism via new readings of the challenging metaphysics of spinoza. He is also one of the leading exponents of french marxist philosophy and the author of spinoza and politics, the philosophy of marx and coauthor of. He has since written on a wide variety of political topics, including racism, nationalism, immigration, war, democracy, and the european constitution.
839 833 843 1587 1336 80 93 716 282 1044 1387 439 453 156 196 418 1288 184 218 275 741 148 628 811 1540 1591 1213 684 724 686 293 931 936 1160 259 574